The spaghetti Western genre, a phenomenon born in the mid-1960s, surged to prominence with such velocity that its rapid commercialisation became both its greatest strength and fatal flaw. By the time Death Rides a Horse (1967) emerged, the market was saturated with formulaic tales of vengeance, sun-scorched deserts, and morally ambiguous antiheroes. Giulio Petroni’s film, while competently crafted, epitomises the genre’s creative exhaustion. The proliferation of identical tropes—bandit raids, lone wanderers, and dusty frontier towns—coupled with the recycling of actors, costumes, and the now-iconic Almería landscapes (standing in for the American Southwest), rendered many entries in the genre indistinguishable. Even films of merit, such as Petroni’s, struggled against the shadow of Sergio Leone’s operatic grandeur, Damiano Damiani’s moral complexity, or the nihilistic edge of Sergio Corbucci’s Django. Death Rides a Horse, despite its technical polish and moments of grit, fails to transcend these limitations, offering instead a familiar narrative dressed in the trappings of a genre already nearing self-parody.
The script, originally titled Da uomo a uomo (From Man to Man), bears the fingerprints of Luciano Vincenzoni, a writer whose earlier collaborations with Leone—For a Few Dollars More (1965) and The Good, the Bad and the Ugly (1966)—helped define the genre’s golden age. Vincenzoni’s falling-out with Leone following The Good, the Bad and the Ugly freed him to craft this tale, though the influence of his previous work lingers. The plot opens with a harrowing massacre at the Mesita ranch, where a wealthy family is slaughtered by masked bandits. The patriarch is killed outright, while his wife and teenage daughter are subjected to rape before being murdered. The sole survivor, a boy named Bill, is spared by a mysterious masked stranger. This traumatic prologue, stark and unflinching, sets the tone for a narrative steeped in vengeance. Fifteen years later, Bill (John Phillip Law), now a brooding gunslinger, embarks on a quest to identify and kill the bandits. His path intersects with Ryan (Lee Van Cleef), a hardened outlaw recently released from prison after a 15-year stint, orchestrated by the same gang who betrayed him during a heist. Their uneasy alliance—fueled by shared targets—sees them pursue the gang’s new identities: Burt Cavanaugh (Anthony Dawson), a suave saloon owner, and Walcott (Luigi Pistilli), a corrupt banker. Walcott’s decision to rob his own bank and escape to Mexico culminates in a showdown in a Mexican village, where the past finally collides with the present.
For all its structural familiarity, Death Rides a Horse is not without merit. It is a decent piece of genre cinema, elevated by its willingness to confront the brutality at the heart of its narrative. The opening massacre, stark and devoid of romanticism, is a rare moment of unvarnished horror in a genre often accused of glamorising violence. Yet the film’s reliance on well-worn conventions undermines its impact. The Almería backdrops, while visually arresting, feel like relics of a thousand earlier films. The casting of Leone regulars Luigi Pistilli and Mario Brega as heavies reinforces the sense of déjà vu. Lee Van Cleef, a stalwart of the genre, exudes his trademark stoicism, yet even his presence cannot fully compensate for the film’s pacing issues. The final act, a confused melee of gunfire and horseback chases, lacks the clarity or emotional payoff of a classic Leone climax. John Phillip Law, though physically imposing, struggles to command the screen. His Bill is earnest but one-dimensional, lacking Clint Eastwood’s sardonic edge or the psychological depth of Lee Van Cleef’s Ryan. The chemistry between the two leads is serviceable but never transcendent, their partnership feeling more utilitarian than symbiotic.
Petroni’s direction, while competent, reveals the limitations of an auteur striving to emulate his peers. The film’s early scenes—particularly the haunting flashbacks to Bill’s childhood trauma—are starkly atmospheric, shot in washed-out hues that evoke the lingering scars of violence. Ennio Morricone’s score, a pulsing blend of twangy guitars and mournful horns, elevates several sequences, its influence later evident in Quentin Tarantino’s Kill Bill (2003-2004). Yet Petroni’s handling of action is erratic; the climax, meant to resolve the protagonists’ intertwined fates, devolves into a muddled sequence of cross-cutting and unclear stakes. Vincenzoni’s script attempts to inject substance through subtext, notably in its critique of how criminal wealth facilitates social ascent—a theme embodied by Pistilli’s Walcott, who manipulates the justice system to erase his past. This thread, though underdeveloped, hints at a sharper political consciousness, suggesting that the real villains are not the bandits themselves but the structures that enable their reinvention.
Ultimately, Death Rides a Horse is a film of contradictions. It aspires to the moral complexity of Leone’s work while clinging to the genre’s more pedestrian instincts. Its technical elements—Morricone’s score, the stark cinematography, and Van Cleef’s weathered gravitas—elevate it above the worst of the spaghetti Western pack, yet its narrative and thematic ambitions are constrained by the weight of its predecessors. The film’s greatest weakness is not its execution but its timidity; it gestures toward deeper themes of corruption and redemption without fully committing to them. For every moment of originality—a harrowing prologue, a cynical glance at capitalist hypocrisy—it retreats into formula. In the crowded landscape of 1960s Italian Westerns, Death Rides a Horse remains a competent but forgettable entry, a casualty of a genre that burned brightly and briefly, leaving only echoes of its former glory.
RATING: 6/10 (++)
Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com
Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/
InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo
Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax
InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo
Rising Star game: https://www.risingstargame.com?referrer=drax
1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7
BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk9
